|There is alot wrong in this picture according to CBS/Paramount.|
I admire the love, devotion and skill Peters has demonstrated with the making of the 'Axanar Works' but he doesn't seem to have a strong defense, even if he cites "fair use." The fair use doctrine would provide protection if he were making a parody like this In Living Color "Star Trek" skit or if he were commenting upon or critiquing Star Trek for the purposes of a documentary.
I am not sure what was happening during the development meetings for 'Axanar' but had I been there, my script clearance report would have listed all the things in the script he needed to get permission from CBS/Paramount for. And, in the alternative, I would have suggested ways he could have made his film in line with a fair use defense. But it is too late for that now and either Peters somehow successfully negotiates for the rights and licenses or his film gets shut down.
If you want to know more about script clearances, getting permission and ways to avoid copyright infringement lawsuits, contact me at firstname.lastname@example.org.